Call for Greater Transparency in Professional Indemnity Insurance

2

AFCA has expressed the need to access information that extends beyond the "corporate veil" involved in scenarios of administration or liquidation. The appeal comes amid background discussions with the Senate Economics References Committee, focusing on the surge in complaints it faced following the downfall of Dixon Advisory.

AFCA emphasized that even though financial services licensees are legally obligated to carry PI insurance, this insurance is not structured to function as a consumer compensation tool. AFCA outlined several limitations of current PI insurance, illustrating why it might not fully serve consumers seeking redress:

• Available funds under the PI insurance might be insufficient to cover awarded compensation.
• Insurance contracts may exclude coverage for specific actions that led to the compensation award.
• The compensation amount might fall below the policy excess, leaving consumers uncompensated.
• Complainants cannot directly file a claim on a firm's PI policy, lacking transparency over claim denials and unable to contest them.
• Services may be claimed on years later, at which point the firm's insurance could have expired, especially when 'run-off' cover is inaccessible or costly.

The authority stated, "AFCA does not have jurisdiction concerning professional indemnity insurers," adding that once it makes a decision, the implicated financial firm has 30 days to comply with the determination, after which AFCA has limited oversight regarding the firm's actions.

"In general, it is assumed compensation payments come directly from firms' operational accounts, unless a firm manages to hedge against the risk through their insurance which varies widely," AFCA observed.

Furthermore, if a firm fails to heed an AFCA determination, consumers are advised to report this to the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), as noted by AFCA.

Notably, AFCA considers that "PII is crucial for ensuring compensation against misconduct is served" and stresses that a solid Professional Indemnity Insurance framework is vital for upholding the Compensation Scheme of Last Resort (CSLR).

In the current regulatory landscape, AFCA is frequently uninformed about whether an advice licensee maintains a relevant PII policy with applicable clauses that would affect AFCA's evaluation of complaints, such as exclusions for certain advice forms or whether the coverage limit has already been reached.

The original insights were facilitated by article discussions from the Senate Economics References Committee and sourced from an industry report featured on Financial Planning's AFCA section.

Published:Monday, 2nd Dec 2024
Source: Paige Estritori

Share this news item:

Insurance News

Clear

Tasmanian Government Insurance Proposal Faces Industry Backlash 07 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori The Tasmanian government's recent proposal to establish a state-run insurance entity has drawn significant criticism from key players in the insurance industry. The plan, spearheaded by Premier Jeremy Rockliff, aims to expand the Motor Accidents Insurance Board into a broader service named TasInsure, offering products including home and contents insurance, small business coverage, and more. The RACT, a major player in Tasmania's insurance sector, expressed considerable concern, labelling the initiative as a simplistic answer to complex problems. - read more

Asbestos Scare Leaves Hospitality Business Uninsured 04 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori The discovery of asbestos-contaminated mulch in a Sydney park led to the cancellation of a festival, resulting in significant financial losses for a hospitality business. Despite these setbacks, the company's claim for coverage under its business interruption (BI) policy was rejected. - read more

Landmark NSW Decision: Dog Walking Costs Covered in Car Crash Injury Claims 03 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori In a groundbreaking decision by the NSW Personal Injury Commission, an insurer has been directed to cover the costs of dog walking services for a car crash victim. The commission ruled that these services classify as domestic assistance under the state’s Motor Accident Injuries Act. This case could pave the way for broader interpretations of 'attendant care services' for claimants. - read more

Extreme Weather Drives $1.8 Billion in First Half Losses for Australian Insurers 03 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori Extreme weather events in Australia have resulted in significant financial impacts for insurers, tallying $1.83 billion in losses during the first half of the year. This comes as insurance companies gear up for further claims linked to ongoing severe weather in New South Wales. - read more

ClearView Names New Underwriting Head Amidst Strategic Changes 30 Jun 2025: Paige Estritori ASX-listed life insurer ClearView has announced the appointment of Peter Tilocca as Head of Underwriting, coinciding with key updates to its underwriting standards and definitions. Tilocca's extensive two-decade career in Australian underwriting includes leadership roles at Zurich, Noble Oak, One Path Life, and RGA Australia. His new role with ClearView commenced on 30 June. - read more